Foundations of Adoption: Aligning Customer Success and Product Maturity
2024 41 min

Foundations of Adoption: Aligning Customer Success and Product Maturity


Unlocking customer value hinges on timely feature adoption tailored to their maturity. This session will explore how to forge a symbiotic relationship with customers, guiding them to adopt the right features at the right stages of their journey. Discover the concept of Product Maturity and how it diverges from traditional metrics. Learn from case studies where Product Maturity models significantly influenced product roadmaps and drove enhanced customer retention, accelerated adoption, and aligned business outcomes. Join us to see how these models can transform your customer success strategy.



0:00

I'm Paulina Rodriguez. I'm a CSM here at Gain site.

0:03

And I'm just going to go through some housekeeping items that you may have

0:05

already heard, but just as a refresher.

0:07

If you have questions throughout the session, please put that in the Slido app

0:12

for Track 2.

0:14

We'll answer those at the end.

0:16

If you like one of the questions, please just upvote those so we can prioritize

0:20

the ones that most of the people want to answer.

0:23

And we will be sending the recording and the deck at the end of polls, so be on

0:27

the lookout for that.

0:29

So without further ado, I'm excited to announce-- sorry, foundations of

0:32

adoption, aligning customer success and product maturity.

0:35

So we're going to kick it off with Save and Brab.

0:38

Let's give a round of applause, everyone.

0:40

[applause]

0:41

Thank you.

0:42

Thank you. That was a little bit of a post-lunch applause, but that's okay.

0:48

So who had the pasta? Raise your hand if you had the pasta. Okay, oh boy.

0:54

Take note of those hands that raise. They may need to be nudged a little bit as

0:59

we go through this because, you know--

1:02

Good afternoon, everybody. I am really excited to be here, and I want to start

1:07

off by asking a question.

1:09

Does anybody know what the definition of reality is?

1:13

Everyone's like, "I don't want to raise my hand and answer that."

1:17

The definition of reality is when your expectations do not meet your experience

1:24

At this point in customer success, we're at a point where reality is smacking

1:29

us in the face.

1:31

How do I know?

1:32

Many of you have seen this recent study from Bain that had seen a decline in

1:39

net revenue retention since FY22.

1:43

Well, at the same time, their customer success costs had gone up by 60%.

1:48

And to make things worse, 66% of the customers said they had not received value

1:53

from the product in the way that they expected.

1:56

Now, I don't completely agree with all of the conclusions Bain comes to in

2:00

terms of how to fix this, but those are alarming statistics.

2:04

And I think they underscore the need to take a look at how we manage customer

2:09

engagements and retention.

2:12

So, as you mentioned, my name is Saben Brab, and I'm going to be talking to you

2:15

guys today about a process methodology

2:18

that we believe, if you start to think differently and implement differently,

2:22

can radically improve those metrics.

2:27

I'm going to go through three main pieces today.

2:29

I'm going to go a little bit more into diagnosis and what some of the solutions

2:32

could possibly be.

2:34

And then I'll talk to you guys about what a product maturity model is and how

2:38

it's been implemented.

2:39

And then, of course, as we mentioned, questions. There's always a lot of

2:41

questions around this topic, so that's fantastic.

2:45

So, let's go ahead and dive in.

2:48

The lens through which customer success as an industry is viewed has been very

2:52

well established by gain site and many others in the industry.

2:56

I'm sure a lot of you are familiar with this framework, but for those that aren

2:59

't, I just wanted to real quickly kind of walk through

3:03

what these individual stages mean so that we can all be on the same page to

3:08

establish where we are today.

3:11

First stage is just the initial stage you recognize as your need for customer

3:15

success, you form a team,

3:18

you begin to reactively support customers. I'm sure we're all at least there

3:21

since we're sitting in this room.

3:23

From there, the organization matures into more proactive touches, QBRs, things

3:28

like that,

3:29

and begins to explore health scores and MPS and that sort of thing.

3:34

The next level is taking customer journey and the associated handoffs and very

3:40

clearly defining them from sales to onboarding,

3:44

onboarding to customer success and so on. And most of those touches are very

3:48

proactive.

3:49

And then finally, we get to a level of optimization where we have very scalable

3:54

and accurate metrics that are built into all of the processes.

3:58

And that allows us to have very flexible cadences and likely there's also a

4:03

very robust digital customer success motion.

4:06

Now, those are very basic definitions and there's variation from company to

4:10

company, but I hope that sets the stage for us taking a look at where we are

4:15

today as an industry.

4:16

If you look at studies from Gainsite, Bain, TSA, and pretty much anybody else I

4:21

've seen that has studied the industry,

4:24

the majority of customer success organizations are towards the lower end of

4:28

this spectrum.

4:29

They're very rarely are they reaching the established level and even rare are

4:34

still getting to that level of optimization.

4:38

This is echoed in my experience working with customers, different companies.

4:43

I'm sure it's echoed in your experience as well.

4:45

Maybe for lucky, one in 100 are reaching level of optimization, but

4:50

unfortunately it's probably closer to one in a thousand.

4:53

So we need to break this stagnation.

4:57

There's something that's missing.

4:59

There's a critical missing piece, bless you, a critical missing piece that is

5:04

keeping us from getting to this level of optimization and predictability that

5:08

we want to get to.

5:10

Now, I believe we have a unique opportunity at this moment in the history of

5:15

our very young industry to reframe how we approach customers and the customer

5:21

journey.

5:23

I believe that we need a process methodology that is fully collaborative with

5:30

the customer that has a shared view, a shared roadmap with goals and milestones

5:38

that we both agree to and are aligned on.

5:39

And the outcomes are associated with those goals.

5:43

There has been some studies recently that have shown that 85% of customers buy

5:47

a product without a strong understanding of what their own organizational

5:52

maturity should look like.

5:54

85% is a big number.

5:57

Of course, customers are going to buy your product with specific, bless you,

6:01

allergic customer success.

6:05

Customers are going to buy your product with a specific need in mind.

6:09

And of course, we want to meet that need and exceed their expectations in doing

6:12

that.

6:13

But at the same time, I think we really do ourselves as a company and the

6:18

customer a disservice if we're not providing them with a view of what great

6:24

organizational maturity can look like and how using the totality of our product

6:28

can help them to get there.

6:31

Now, I'm sure we all have that person at our company, maybe it's you, who knows

6:36

the product just inside and out.

6:38

Maybe it's a senior customer success manager, sales engineer, somebody like

6:42

that, who knows all the features.

6:44

They know how everything integrates together. They know all the use cases.

6:47

They can talk to customers about it in a way that's very organic and helps the

6:52

customer to see a vision of what can be with the product.

6:57

Now, if we could clone that person 100 times over, we'd have the best customer

7:02

success organization in the industry and our attention rates would go through

7:06

the roof.

7:07

But of course, we know in the real world that's not possible.

7:10

And so we need a way to share that knowledge in a way that's very easy to

7:14

consume and easy to communicate with all of our customer success managers,

7:19

regardless of how long they've been with the company.

7:22

It'd be great, too, if we could share that knowledge directly with the

7:26

customers in a way that's easy for them to consume and to put some actions

7:31

against.

7:32

It's not just about customer success managers, though. It's also about customer

7:35

success leadership.

7:36

Customer success leadership, of course, needs to be able to allocate resources

7:40

very efficiently and effectively in this just maelstrom of competing priorities

7:47

and tasks and changes to the product and the ever-present pressure ofization.

7:51

So what we really need is we need to put it simply the ability to communicate,

8:01

measure, and share the customer journey and the plan to improve with everyone

8:08

that needs to know from the customer all the way up to our own internal

8:12

executive leadership team.

8:14

That sounds easy, right?

8:16

No, it's not easy.

8:18

But it is possible through product maturity models.

8:24

So what is product maturity?

8:26

So this is kind of the high-level definition.

8:28

I'm going to break a speaker rule, and I'm going to read my own slide.

8:31

Product maturity is the degree to which a customer fully leverages a product's

8:36

features and capabilities, driving both their intended outcomes and uncovering

8:41

new opportunities for value they may not have been aware of.

8:45

It's essentially measuring a customer from a customer not using it all, all the

8:50

way up to mastery of the product and the brilliant outcomes that they achieve

8:54

by being at that level of mastery, and then the levels in between.

8:58

Now, I want to pause for a minute here, because oftentimes I start talking

9:02

about product maturity models.

9:04

There's the inevitable confusion between that and product usage.

9:09

So product usage, in general, is a measurement that's a lot more binary.

9:15

You're measuring if a customer is using a specific feature, or how many people

9:20

are logging in, or are they using all of the licenses they purchase, that sort

9:23

of thing.

9:24

Product maturity is looking at how they're using the features.

9:28

It is the quality of interactions, not just quantities and checking boxes.

9:33

So there's an example I show from that we built at SolarWinds that kind of

9:37

further illustrates this that I'll get to in a few minutes, but I at least

9:43

wanted to kind of put a pin in that, so that's separate in everybody's minds as

9:47

we go through this.

9:48

So let's go ahead and start talking about what a product maturity model is here

9:55

So the first step, and this is really the cornerstone of building a product

9:59

maturity model, is this is as the cornerstone is incredibly important.

10:04

If you do this well, the rest of the pieces start to really flow.

10:09

We score the best and highest level of five.

10:12

Not that could be a four, it could be a different number, so don't get too hung

10:16

up on that specifically, but this is what we've done historically.

10:21

So we're going to define what great looks like, what does it look like for a

10:25

customer to use our product in an amazing way.

10:29

You don't want to hold yourself back based on current telemetry and reporting

10:33

you have today, although that will be important when we get to talking about KP

10:36

Is.

10:37

And you also don't want to get too tied up into how the customers are using the

10:40

product today.

10:41

This might be aspirational, but you want to take a step back and really

10:45

understand what a great usage of the product could look like.

10:50

You want to take a look at the depth of their usage.

10:55

Are they using the very advanced features to do very complex tasks?

10:59

You want to cross-functional teams that should be using it.

11:02

Do they have integrations with third parties and potentially even customers?

11:05

You want to look at the maturity of their implementation.

11:09

Are they using the features, all of the features in very advanced ways?

11:13

And then fidelity of engagement, which is the data very accurate.

11:18

Are they consistently using best practices and that sort of thing?

11:22

Now, stepping outside the product maturity model, this one step actually has a

11:27

trinal company should do,

11:29

is to have a very clear view of what this looks like.

11:32

It can be used outside of this process methodology for instant sales and

11:38

marketing to create the ideal customer profile.

11:41

It can be used to create sales and marketing plays, potentially for your own

11:45

internal onboarding for employees,

11:48

for product to understand the scope of the product and are there features

11:52

either that aren't there or features that maybe are not necessary for investors

11:58

and many, many other things.

12:00

So this one step has a huge amount of value even outside of the model, but let

12:05

's go ahead and move on with kind of building out the rest of the scale here.

12:10

So once we've got that level five, that just truly brilliant, amazing mastery

12:16

level definition,

12:18

from there we start to reverse engineer less mature, three is kind of middle

12:22

maturity, two lower maturity,

12:24

one maybe one or two features being used, and zero being they're not using at

12:28

all,

12:29

which hopefully is just a customer that hasn't been onboarded yet.

12:35

This takes some time and it takes some iterating kind of massaging these back

12:39

and forth till you really get to a point where you feel like it's solid,

12:42

or about that towards the end, but you really want to make sure that you work

12:46

hard to kind of get this right,

12:48

and once you feel like it's solid, it's a good idea to pressure test it cross

12:51

functionally, potentially even with customers,

12:54

because again this is going to be shared, it is going to be a shared roadmap

12:57

with them.

12:58

But once you feel like you've got that pretty solid, the next step is to

13:01

extract the outcomes that customers will see

13:04

by actually having conversations with customers and looking at whatever data

13:09

you can gather,

13:10

and start to understand what those outcomes are, make them very crisp, make

13:14

them very concise,

13:15

and in some cases as you're doing this part of it, it starts to inform changes

13:21

to the actual level definitions again backwards,

13:23

and it can kind of do where you feel like you've got this pretty solid, you've

13:26

got great product level definitions,

13:29

you feel good about those, and you've got the accompanying outcomes, and you

13:32

feel good about those.

13:34

Once you've got to that point, you have created your shared roadmap that we're

13:39

talking about,

13:40

that we're envisioning for what we can use with customers, but this is actually

13:44

just where the fun starts.

13:46

So after you've got all of those, to each one of those levels, and that's going

13:52

to be again,

13:54

hopefully you have good telemetry reporting, I would say that if you don't,

13:58

this is a great opportunity to have a very clear idea

14:02

of what telemetry would be important that product can then take and go and use,

14:06

but hopefully you're looking for even distribution, right? We've got

14:09

definitions, and so part of what the learning is going to be here

14:13

is what is our distribution? Maybe 3% of your customers are at level 5, that's

14:18

great to know.

14:20

It may be also just across, as they fall across, there may be some interesting

14:23

things you can learn about

14:25

what customer segments fit and differ. That can be really helpful as well.

14:30

So you've got the customers mapped out in this way, and now you can start to

14:35

get into some really amazing data analysis,

14:39

and get some incredible context. You can apply these levels.

14:43

Again, we're talking about customer segments. You see certain customer segments

14:46

come up a lot more in certain levels than others.

14:49

There's a lot of different pieces that you can begin to extract, and I think

14:52

that's fantastic as well.

14:55

Now, when I first built this seven years ago, there wasn't really a lot of AI

15:00

available, and so that makes this really powerful, right?

15:04

So you get to a point where you can start to do machine learning to help

15:08

customers to be assigned to levels

15:10

and consistently reviewed to see if they're shifting or adjusting, which is

15:15

going to become very important

15:17

as we start to talk about some of the use cases.

15:22

So this is the SolarWinds example I wanted to give you that kind of lays this

15:25

out to kind of help to understand

15:28

in a very simple way what we're talking about and we're talking about maturity.

15:33

So this is their IT service management suite, and you can see I've got a yellow

15:36

box around the incident's portions.

15:40

So this is, we'll talk through kind of what these different levels are. You

15:45

start with obviously starting, which is a zero.

15:47

They haven't started to use it yet. The first level is ticketing, which is just

15:50

real simple.

15:51

The ability to do ticketing and logging incidents. From there it goes up to

15:55

level two, which is incident management,

15:58

which takes that ticketing concept and builds on kind of managing the overall

16:02

life cycle of it,

16:03

which is helping to look at figuring out where there's trends and things like

16:09

that and gets even more sophisticated.

16:11

And then finally at the level four, the highest level, it's incident prevention

16:16

So it's all those other things, but then it's also looking to actually prevent

16:20

incidents from taking place.

16:22

Now you can see that as a customer moves up, they shall maturity.

16:27

So an IT director who buys this product to do ticketing and only does ticketing

16:32

with it is going to be a lot less successful as an organization

16:36

than somebody that buys this and goes all the way to incident management is

16:39

actually preventing incidents from happening.

16:41

That's a very important piece to this. The other thing I would note is if as a

16:46

CSM, we're very focused on working with that IT director

16:50

on being brilliant at that first step of yet to share with them that they can

16:55

do incident management,

16:57

we are at risk of churn for a couple of reasons. One being there may be some

17:02

very lean product that just does ticketing

17:05

that comes along and they're a lot less expensive. And if they don't understand

17:08

, this may feel like a very expensive tool for doing ticketing.

17:12

The other side is a competitor could come along and talk about incident

17:15

understanding they've got that as an option within what they already own.

17:19

Then that can be churned as well.

17:23

So just kind of pause for a moment with kind of how this is all built out.

17:28

It is hard. It is hard to build a product maturity model. It takes some work.

17:33

It takes a lot of cross functional cooperation.

17:36

But once you've built that, there are some amazing was when we built this seven

17:42

years ago, this one insight was like my aha, mind-blower moment

17:48

that has led me to where I'm standing on a stage about half the earth away from

17:53

where I live to talk about it.

17:55

So this first step, and I found this in every single time I built this, a

18:00

golden step has existed.

18:03

So these numbers are actual, actual numbers from the first product I built this

18:06

for, although they're rounded so they're easier to read.

18:09

But these numbers have been pretty similar with the other products I've built

18:13

this for.

18:14

So we have a technical jump from one level to the next where the retention rate

18:19

goes from unacceptable to exceptional in one step.

18:24

It's one big jump.

18:26

Now you can see here that level two, we had an 84% gross retention, which was

18:32

well below our target.

18:34

Our target I think was 92%.

18:37

And level three was above that, obviously, at 96%.

18:41

The brilliance in this is that we know who the customers are, they're level two

18:48

We also know, because of our definitions, what would make them a level three.

18:53

And so what we were able to do is to apply a very focused message to those

18:59

level two customers that was directing them towards moving up in maturity to a

19:05

level.

19:06

And then we went in product, we did marketing support for it, we did our normal

19:10

customer success touches through the phone and email, and webinars and

19:15

everything.

19:16

And the result of that was a 7% jump in our gross retention rate in our biggest

19:22

quarter, which was mind blowing.

19:25

So that was incredible.

19:30

So I want to talk about earning for us was worth doing the project, as you can

19:34

tell.

19:35

But we've started to figure out some other ways to use product maturity model.

19:38

And so I'm going to talk about four, probably, the more critical things that we

19:42

deal with in customer success today.

19:45

First off, I'll talk about resource allocation and how that can be much more

19:48

efficient using product maturity model.

19:51

We'll deal with the effort within a company.

19:54

How, when combined with some of this AI sentiment analysis, the risk remed

20:00

iation can be vastly earlier in terms of how we're seeing red flags.

20:04

And then some ways that this can help to structure digital.

20:07

So the folks resource allocation is amazing.

20:11

One of the first principles of growth that we teach at high achiever is to

20:14

apply your resources on the most critical growth path.

20:18

And this is absolutely one of the best tools I found to do this.

20:21

So we know that getting somebody to a one is very manageable.

20:25

We also get somebody to a five is going to be pretty challenging.

20:29

The irony is that while a level five customer is almost guaranteed to renew,

20:36

the amount of effort it is worth.

20:39

It is getting to a level three, which is much more manageable.

20:42

And you get almost the same return there.

20:44

So to kind of think through how I would, this is a very simple model, grant you

20:49

, of potential resource allocation here.

20:52

It's going to take my onboarding staff and I'm going to apply them to level

20:55

zero customers.

20:56

And their goal is going to be to get them to a level two.

20:59

Great KPI for onboarding, by the way.

21:01

Now we know that as they go through that process, there's going to be a number

21:05

of customers only make it to level one as they go through the onboarding

21:08

process.

21:09

And so I'm going to apply my junior CSMs to moving level one customer to level

21:14

two.

21:15

And my seniors from moving customer to level two to level three.

21:19

And then we'll build KPIs around all of those activities.

21:22

Now the level four and five customers, I'm going to do some standard kind of

21:26

cadence interactions, but I'm not going to put a lot of cycles into them.

21:31

I'm going to apply a lot of different very low touch, tech touch kind of VIP

21:36

motions.

21:37

One of my favorites is creating a gated part of the community for very mature

21:42

customers to be able to interact with each other.

21:45

That feels like a VIP kind of experience.

21:48

Skipping up to a higher level of technical support because they're going to be

21:52

able to operate at a higher level and that saves time.

21:56

Some specialized digital customer success touches that are built towards mature

22:00

customers, that sort of thing.

22:02

In doing this, we are going to have a large impact on retention, but we're

22:06

going to be very efficient and very effective in how we do it.

22:10

So that's kind of a high level of some focused resource allocation thoughts.

22:14

Now there has been a challenge since the dawn of time, or maybe it would be

22:19

less melodramatic since customer success became a practice,

22:24

which is quantifying the impact of the customer success organization on the

22:27

overall company.

22:29

This has always been huge.

22:32

We believe that in using the product maturity model, we've come up, we show the

22:36

value of customer success in any company that's using this.

22:41

It's called the maturity growth score.

22:44

So we established with the golden step that there is that jump.

22:48

So this creates an organic cut line between the maturity levels where the

22:53

retention rates are unacceptable and too low,

22:56

and the maturity rates that are almost up at 100% are exceptional.

23:00

And so what we do to create the maturity growth, figure out the percentage of

23:05

our revenue that's above that cut line.

23:08

In doing that, we then create a baseline and see where we're at from there.

23:13

And then we know that if we increase the maturity growth score, we're going to

23:17

increase our retention rates.

23:20

And that is to measure the overall customer base.

23:25

You can use it to measure individual teams, customer success managers, and

23:29

their specific accounts, customer segments, whatever you want to measure.

23:34

But you know that you're going to be measuring exactly what we do in customer

23:38

success,

23:39

the way that the customer is using the product to actually get them to become

23:42

more mature in the product and to get to a better place.

23:45

And so in doing that, that has a direct impact on retention, which has a direct

23:48

impact on revenue.

23:50

Therefore, the maturity growth score is a direct correlation between what we're

23:54

doing and the actual revenue that we're driving within the company.

23:58

Without it being, we're in charge of renewals and expansion.

24:01

Right? So, a math equation, essentially.

24:06

And anybody who knows math knows, if you can take an equation one way, you can

24:11

take it the other way.

24:12

So the other thing that we've done is when you're handed a retention rate

24:16

target,

24:17

you then just can reverse engineer that and understand what your maturity

24:20

growth score needs to be in order to hit that new target.

24:24

And you also know that since you have the ability, what have you, on moving

24:28

customers up that golden step to get there,

24:31

that you have a very tactical way to go after that retention rate that actually

24:36

makes a difference for the customers and makes a difference for you guys.

24:41

Another thing I'd mention on this, just overall, is this is very powerful at

24:45

the executive level as well.

24:47

I've seen the maturity growth score go up.

24:52

Then you can apply that to next year's expirations and next year's ARR and

24:58

understand with a lot better solidity what that revenue is going to look like,

25:04

and therefore you can budget against that and make other plans.

25:06

So that's been really powerful as well.

25:13

So risk remediation, so this is one where we talked about product usage, health

25:20

score,

25:21

we've got the meme for a reason that the customer is green and they churn.

25:25

So there's all these things that it happens too late.

25:28

And what we've seen is we talked about product usage being very binary.

25:33

They're using the feature, they're not.

25:35

I'm sure you've all seen the customer who's, that's all great until all of a

25:38

sudden they flip over and they move to your competitor.

25:41

The product maturity model allows for a view into a nuance of how they're using

25:46

the product.

25:48

And that changes way earlier than anything else.

25:51

So they might be still using all the features, but the way they're using them

25:55

starts to change very early on.

25:57

And that then impacts, now of course as I mentioned before, you combine this

26:01

with like what Staircase does and customer sentiment analysis

26:04

and all of a sudden you're in a world where you are able to see that there's a

26:09

shift in the customer long before you ever would have before

26:12

and actually have a chance to remediate it instead of it being just too far

26:17

over the cliff.

26:19

Finally, digital self-serve.

26:23

So you've built this amazing roadmap, this structure, you've got this product

26:27

maturity model.

26:28

There's no reason to share with them.

26:30

We want to show them what they can achieve.

26:33

And so if you've got this product maturity model built, you can put it in

26:36

product in portal.

26:38

AI is a big piece of this where you're making sure that through machine

26:42

learning and that sort of thing that they are being placed there.

26:45

You explain to them what the product maturity model is and where they are at,

26:50

where they can be, the outcomes they can get from that.

26:53

And then with LLMs and that sort of thing, you can then guide them up through

26:57

the maturity journey that way.

26:59

This also, by the way, is a great onboarding tool for your teams as they're

27:03

coming on.

27:04

And it also going to be used as an onboarding tool in general for your

27:07

customers.

27:08

So that's pretty powerful as well.

27:13

So we're really at a crossroads.

27:15

I think that we're hearing this message over and over again.

27:18

We all recognize it, we feel it.

27:21

There are some things that we've done in the past that are not going to work

27:24

going forward.

27:25

And I think that some are current.

27:29

I would suggest that you have an opportunity to go back to your company to

27:34

influence the building of a product maturity model

27:38

and to have a chance to have your company start to be on the leading edge of

27:42

this as you go forward.

27:44

Now, I've seen a lot of nods and a lot of recognition that this makes sense.

27:50

And so the next step is kind of like, well, how do we get started?

27:53

So this is not rocket science, but you need a cross-functional team of subject

27:57

matter experts.

27:59

It's going to be product, it's going to be customer success, sales, sales

28:02

engineering, BI, some of your best AIP.

28:06

In general, depending on what your telemetry is like, the complexity of your

28:10

product, all those sorts of things,

28:12

it can take as much as nine to 15 months to build, which can feel a little bit

28:18

daunting.

28:19

But to really build something out that is exceptional and has the opportunity

28:23

to change the company in the way that this can,

28:25

I have seen it be worth it for sure.

28:29

All of who works at the company, who may know something about how to do this,

28:32

consultants or contractors or people that can help, that can really shorten

28:36

that timeframe quite a bit.

28:39

I'm going to get to questions in just a second here.

28:46

But before I go, I'm going to throw a QR code up on here.

28:49

This is just a little freebie for putting up with me.

28:52

You can choose to bookmark or kind of introducing the concept of a customer

28:55

success operating system,

28:57

which I think is not completely unknown to folks, but to really make sure that

29:00

you have an understanding of how to build out a customer operating system,

29:04

what it looks like, how it provides efficiency.

29:06

And then I've got a little brief module on there about building risk-reason

29:10

codes out of your churn-reason codes and some things around that.

29:14

So if you're interested, that's the QR code for that.

29:18

And with that, I...

29:22

Give me a go back. Did everybody get...

29:28

Oh, okay.

29:30

All right.

29:32

Okay, sorry, it's top here.

29:36

How would you leverage the product maturity model in a low-touch, tech-touch

29:39

approach?

29:40

The steps they have to pursue to get to the next level.

29:42

So this is a great question. I think there's two things in here.

29:47

One is that there can be a hesitance to show the customer, here's how immature

29:55

you are.

29:56

So I understand that.

29:59

So I think that really what you want this to be is...

30:02

Part of how you're communicating this to them is you're getting from that.

30:07

Here's where you can be, and you do want to share that with them.

30:10

There's something that's laid out between you two that you're both working

30:12

through, so it's eyes wide open.

30:14

So yes, you want it to be shared.

30:16

And in terms of, from a digital perspective, a digital low-touch perspective,

30:20

I think, you know, kind of talking through that at a high level with the

30:22

digital customer success slide

30:24

is ranting themselves to it and understanding where they're at and where they

30:28

can be

30:29

and understanding that the outcomes they'll get from that.

30:31

And then the help along the way could be low-touch.

30:34

It could be, you know, fully LLM with AI,

30:37

or it could be through other types of tech-touch motions.

30:41

Ideally, I think probably low-touch of a little bit more known,

30:45

and then a lot of customers start to be able to self-serve better from there.

30:50

What are leading adoption metrics you recommend tracking,

30:54

and do you recommend focusing on golden features to track only adoption of high

30:58

value functionality?

31:00

So there is a lot under the covers of this question

31:05

because this really gets to what is your product, right?

31:08

It's the IT service management suite product maturity model at SolarWinds.

31:13

There's a lot of features in there.

31:16

And so we had to make some choices about kind of some tier one, tier two

31:19

features,

31:20

and you kind of saw where we got to in terms of understanding

31:23

here are the main functions of what the product is doing.

31:26

What are all the features that lead to that main function?

31:31

It's because it's, you really have to be, you have to think through that.

31:34

If you have features in there that you feel like it doesn't really matter

31:40

if they're using this or not, that's a different conversation

31:43

that probably needs to be had with product,

31:45

which probably won't be a fun conversation, depending on who put that in.

31:49

But I think it definitely can be difficult to really dial in and narrow down

31:55

what are the key features and how to track them and stuff.

31:59

There's a lot that has to be done in that.

32:01

This is really the hard work of this, I think.

32:04

Can you give more concrete examples of activities that took customers from

32:09

step two over the golden step?

32:11

What messaging are specific touches resonated best?

32:14

Yeah, so the product we were using was a student assessment tool,

32:21

and there was a, basically the main difference.

32:26

And I try not to get two in the weeds on that as a specific thing,

32:29

but it was essentially that there was a secondary kind of like after quiz

32:35

that level three customers are using, that level two weren't.

32:38

And there's a lot more to it, so I don't want to bore you the details.

32:41

So essentially all we had to do was we went in with messaging that was based

32:44

on that specific feature that was, you know, we have found that schools

32:48

and school districts that leverage this, see a rise in their growth scores by X

32:54

, Y, and Z.

32:56

And here's how you can start to implement that, and we can help you with

33:00

a more detailed plan if you want to.

33:02

So it was that kind of messaging, but it really was, for that product,

33:07

there was literally one specific feature within the product that they needed to

33:11

use to get to level three, and there's other things to get to level four and five

33:14

that were more in depth, but that's basically what it was.

33:19

It can happen that some customers only need to use part of our product features

33:23

so they'll never get to the highest level.

33:25

Would that mean they're not a good fit with our product, or how do they fit in

33:29

this logic? So that's usually the first question I get, because I'll have the customer

33:34

who, going back to the IT service management option,

33:38

they just want to use ticketing, they just want to log tickets,

33:41

they don't want to do anything else.

33:42

They're super happy, they've been with us for ten years, it's all great.

33:46

What I would say is it's a choice, right?

33:50

It's a choice that you have to make.

33:52

Obviously, you don't need to necessarily jettison them, and fire them as a

33:56

customer,

33:57

but you also have to understand that that is going to be a constant source of

34:01

risk,

34:02

because as we talked about, somebody else is going to come along that just does

34:06

the thing they want to do cheaper, or somebody else is going to come along

34:09

and it's going to provide them a vision that they may have not really thought

34:13

through before that you can also do.

34:15

So I think there's always a risk of churn, and there's always going to be a

34:19

lack of

34:20

growth there because they're probably not going to expand,

34:23

and they're probably not going to buy anything else.

34:26

So you could accept that risk, but within the model, they're still going to sit

34:30

probably in level one, and so you're always going to have that as a drag to

34:34

your maturity growth score, but again, it's a choice to make,

34:38

you just have to accept that, that that's the risk you're going to face.

34:43

The concept key considerations that hold true no matter what

34:46

when you're assessing building maturity.

34:49

So that, again, that's a great question.

34:52

I think that it really is holding yourself, this is not as specific as you

34:59

probably want, but holding yourself to a really high standard in terms of that

35:03

highest level definition.

35:05

The challenge we always have in building this is we want to pull back.

35:11

It's like, there's, boy, there's not going to be many, that's, or this is like

35:14

a really robust use of the product.

35:17

But I think that's kind of the key thing is I'd always challenge you is, again,

35:21

to be aspirational at that level five, and just know you're going to reverse

35:25

engineer your way down.

35:27

But really, it's thinking in terms of the logical progression of how a customer

35:33

would generally work through becoming more mature is going to be really

35:37

important.

35:38

So you obviously, you're not going to stick some feature in level two that's a

35:42

very advanced feature that requires other features to work, you know, that kind of

35:45

thing.

35:47

But aside from that, it is so vast that it is difficult for me to say always do

35:53

it this way.

35:55

And I apologize for that.

35:57

I wish I could say do it this way, it will always work.

36:00

But it is difficult.

36:01

It requires a lot of thought and definitely some pressure testing.

36:05

So that was probably the worst answer that you're going to get from any one of

36:11

these sessions today.

36:15

How do you recommend evolving a product maturity model as a product itself

36:19

evolves and new features are added over time?

36:21

Who are the internal stakeholders you've seen take ownership of this process?

36:24

So that is an excellent question.

36:26

So I'm going to cover two things in this question that I think are important to

36:29

note. So number one is when we think about the golden step, that's going to occur in

36:34

different places depending on the company and a lot of other things, right?

36:38

So to give you kind of extreme examples, imagine a new startup that's been

36:42

around for a year and a half.

36:44

Most of their customers are not going to be very advanced to the product yet,

36:47

right? They're going to be probably most of you where that occurs.

36:49

And then as we get five, six, seven years down the line, it's a great start up.

36:54

I recommend investing in it.

36:56

Then that will start to change and that golden step will move.

37:01

In terms of adding features, absolutely, that's going to change the model.

37:05

That's going to have to impact and have you go back and redraw that.

37:09

My recommendation is that there is somebody in the bowl for this because they

37:13

're the

37:14

ones that are going to be knowing ahead of time what we're adding and what

37:17

pieces need to be in there.

37:18

But there should be like a review that includes whatever the cross-functional

37:23

members that need to be a part of that.

37:27

But yeah, but that is great.

37:29

The other side of the -- I'm sorry, I gave you the first example, but not the

37:33

other

37:34

side of that being like imagine a -- like cybersecurity suite, for example,

37:39

where

37:40

there's a -- the risk of not being mature is so high that it may push the

37:45

golden

37:46

step up because customers are adopting so many of the features at a high level.

37:51

So just to kind of give you that side, I'm sorry, I forgot to give you the

37:54

second part of that.

37:55

But yeah, so that's the stakeholders.

37:58

I'm going to do, I think, one more.

38:00

Maybe two.

38:01

We'll see how we get through this.

38:03

Would you say it's desirable for every customer to reach the highest level of

38:06

product maturity or does this differ per segment to customer profile?

38:10

So I think that what we really want is for customers to get above the golden

38:14

step, right?

38:15

And I think that there is a -- and that's not just for us.

38:19

It's not -- because the -- what that's -- so, again, love to reverse engineer.

38:23

So think about it this way.

38:25

If a customer is -- if you've got a group of customers that have a gross

38:29

retention rate of over 96%, they must be going good, right?

38:33

They must be happy with what's happening.

38:35

So if you are getting them to those levels, you're essentially getting them

38:38

into a

38:39

level where they're seeing the value out of the product that we want them to

38:42

see

38:43

and because of that, they're staying.

38:45

So I would say obviously getting everybody up to five would be brilliant.

38:48

That'd be amazing.

38:49

But probably looking at getting them up into those levels where we see that

38:53

level of retention suggests customers are happy when they get to that level.

38:58

So I think probably just this one, then we'll go.

39:02

What about feature releases?

39:04

How do you align these with customer maturity or are they treated independently

39:07

So that's kind of like the other question.

39:09

The real quick version is I just say, again, we want to make sure product is

39:12

heavily involved in the ongoing iterations of this because they're going to

39:15

have a sense of what those things are going to be and how the roadmap could

39:18

potentially

39:19

change.

39:20

One more.

39:21

How much focus should be put on the product maturity model from a risk

39:26

mitigation point of view compared to other risk signals?

39:30

I don't want as many risk signals as I can get, assuming that they're accurate.

39:35

Personally, I think that using a really good customer sentiment tool with the

39:40

product maturity model and kind of combining those efforts into early warning

39:44

is going to give you the best leading indicator of risk.

39:47

You also don't want to go, you know, you want to focus in on the things that

39:51

are, I would say that part of this too is understanding what are you seeing in terms

39:55

of the predictability of that metric?

39:57

Is it actually like truly predicting churn?

39:59

And that's a way that we've seen, again, going back to the drawing board with

40:02

the

40:03

product maturity model before is making a few adjustments in there.

40:07

Although that was, ended up actually putting us right back to where we were,

40:11

so that didn't change anything.

40:13

The golden step actually held true in that one too.

40:17

But yeah, so one more, one minute, quick.

40:22

Okay, I want to be causing the time.

40:24

How do you approach a client company with users that are on different product

40:28

maturity levels?

40:29

Ooh, that's different organizations that are all using the product and they

40:32

have

40:33

different product maturity levels.

40:35

My impression generally is to look at this by breaking this down.

40:39

And this is, this is something I didn't have a chance to talk about today.

40:42

But the real quick high level view is you may have, like in that, in the suite,

40:46

there may be different product maturity levels that a customer may have within

40:49

that suite.

40:50

The same thing would apply for multiple different organizations within the

40:53

customer with different product maturity levels.

40:56

You'd have to kind of work with them and kind of figure that out.

40:58

But you have the understanding, you know what's happening there, and that's

41:01

really probably the most important thing.

41:03

So, good.

41:05

Okay, I better stop there.

41:06

16 seconds.

41:07

Thank you guys so, so much.

41:09

I really appreciate it.

41:11

It's been awesome.

41:12

If you see me around, feel free to ask me more questions.

41:15

But thank you.

41:16

Appreciate it.

41:17

[applause]